Melbourne does gelato as a craft, and the best of it sits in independent gelaterias working their own flavours rather than rolling out a national colour scheme. We ranked the inner-city gelaterias on their Curateria Score and on what diners keep saying across their most recent reviews, with chains and franchises left out, so this is the genuine local scoop. Here is the order this month.
Top of the list is Gelateria on the Docks in Docklands, a 4.87 waterfront gelateria with more than a thousand reviews where the pomegranate sorbet and the Dubai chocolate gelato get called the best ice cream, smooth and silky, by people who keep coming back. Luther's Scoops in Brunswick is the flavour-nerd favourite, a 4.85 room where the brown-butter cheesecake and the earl grey chocolate land verdicts as strong as the best ice cream of my life, and the vegan buckwheat apple crumble has its own fan club.
Beku Gelato Carlton in Carlton is the Southeast-Asian one, a Lygon Street go-to on cendol, durian and pandan gelato that regulars rate for flavours you will not find elsewhere and a consistency they call spot on. GLO GELATO in Carlton is the colourful modern room that wins over the sceptics, a Pistachio Mayhem and an Icky Sticky salted-caramel that prove the looks are not the whole story. Hareruya Pantry in Carlton is the Japanese-style one, a 1150-review room on daifuku mochi-wrapped gelato and a strong matcha that reviewers call a must for Asian-inspired flavours.
Pidapipo CBD in the city is the Degraves classic, a Pidapipo counter on pistachio, bacio and blood-orange sorbet that holidaymakers and locals alike call one of the best ice creams anywhere. Cono Gelateria in Reservoir is worth the drive north, a 4.87 gelateria where the pistachio and the nutella get named the best in Melbourne and the staff get named too. Dolce House Gelato in McKinnon is the after-dinner local, a warm, relaxed room on nutella, pistachio and a loukoumades plate the neighbourhood treats as its own.
The list closes across the inner ring. Bianco Latte in Elwood is the quality-over-everything one, a ricotta-cinnamon and pistachio gelato with a cannoli cart reviewers book for weddings, Pidapipo Carlton in Carlton is the Lygon Street staple where the Nutella-on-Nutella is the order and the queue is part of it, L'Arte Della Gelato in Fitzroy is the 4.93 small-batch room on a Biscoff cheesecake gelato and a salted caramel reviewers return to four visits deep, and Augustus Gelatery - Pascoe Vale in Pascoe Vale rounds it out, a 4.49 gelatery on an espresso scoop and a Snickers that the whole family argues over.
We hold the cohort to a tight inner-Melbourne radius, roughly 15km of the city, and we drop chains and franchises, so what is left reads as the genuine local order. We blend that quality score with how often and how recently diners are still talking about a place. The corpus is Victorian and scored by us. AI reads the reviews. The ranking is arithmetic.
Explore more Gelato across Melbourne on Discover ->
Every venue here is ranked by its Curateria Score, a signal computed from its Google reviews with fake reviews removed and a volume weighting that only lowers thin-review scores. Keep browsing Melbourne, sorted by Curateria Score, on Discover.
More from the Lowdown
Support our work
Reader-supported, ad-light. Three ways to back the work.
Our read on where Melbourne is eating, drawn from the reviews we track. Free, no spam.