Pasta is Melbourne comfort food, and the inner city keeps a deep bench of Italian rooms turning out handmade plates worth the trip. We ranked them by Curateria Score and by what diners keep saying across their most recent reviews, with chains and far suburbs left out. Here is the order this month.
Top of the list is Tono on Borsari in Carlton, a 4.79 room with more than two thousand reviews where a carbonara, a lamb-shank pasta and a seafood plate with mussels and prawns sit behind a red sauce one diner says is so much like nonna's. Vaporetto Bar & Eatery Hawthorn Italian Restaurant est 2014 in Hawthorn follows on a 4.85, a reviewer's favourite Italian in Melbourne for its linguine busara, squid-ink pasta and lamb-ragu gnocchi.
Da Guido La Pasta in Carlton scores a 4.86 on a more refined menu, a wagyu ravioli and squid-ink seafood linguine room where a couple rate a ten-course tasting menu beautifully presented and perfectly timed. Sassy Italian Restaurant in West Melbourne pairs a lamb ravioli and fettuccine carbonara with a sticky date pudding diners keep naming the highlight of the night. Little Black Pig & Sons in Heidelberg scores the list's highest at 4.92, a tasting-menu room with fresh pasta and ragu that reviewers call one of the best value fine-dining experiences in Melbourne, worth the drive from the north west.
Max on Hardware in the city carries the deepest review count on the list, more than five thousand, on a homemade gnocchi buffalino and seafood risotto reviewers rate alongside the terrace and the set menu. ALT PASTA BAR in the city is the pasta-bar pick, a spanner-crab squid-ink pasta and Moreton Bay bug plate counter reviewers single out for the squid ink in particular. Tonda Italian in Preston turns out stuffed gnocchi and a pappardelle lamb ragu in a welcoming room reviewers call fresh and authentic.
The list closes across the inner suburbs. Rick's Place Italian Modern Australian & Gluten Free Restaurant in Kensington is the gluten-free-friendly room, a carbonara and seafood spaghetti allo scoglio kitchen where the owner's welcome draws repeat visits. Scopri Italian Food and Wine in Carlton runs handmade duck-ragu and pumpkin-agnolotti pasta with a truffle risotto reviewers rate among the best Italian in the city, Piccolo Mondo in Carlton backs a squid-ink spaghetti and seafood risotto with service reviewers name by waiter, and Berth in Docklands rounds it out, a fresh-seafood-pasta and scallop room diners call exceptional for a celebration.
Every kitchen here carries a Curateria Score drawn from its whole review history, then re-weighted toward the most recent hundred reviews so the order reflects how the kitchen cooks today rather than how it cooked two years ago. We hold the cohort to a tight inner-Melbourne radius, roughly 15km of the city, and drop the multi-location chains, so what is left reads as the real local order rather than a list of the loudest brands. That quality score is then blended with how often and how recently diners are still talking about a place. The corpus is Victorian and scored by us; no AI writer ever reads it. The ranking is arithmetic. The words are ours.
Explore more Pasta across Melbourne on Discover ->
Every venue here is ranked by its Curateria Score, a recent-review-weighted quality signal that leans on what diners are saying now, not years ago. Keep browsing Melbourne, sorted by Curateria Score, on Discover.
More from the Lowdown
Support our work
Reader-supported, ad-light. Three ways to back the work.
Pasta is Melbourne comfort food, and the inner city keeps a deep bench of Italian rooms turning out handmade plates worth the trip. We ranked them by Curateria Score and by what diners keep saying across their most recent reviews, with chains and far suburbs left out. Here is the order this month.
Top of the list is Tono on Borsari in Carlton, a 4.79 room with more than two thousand reviews where a carbonara, a lamb-shank pasta and a seafood plate with mussels and prawns sit behind a red sauce one diner says is so much like nonna's. Vaporetto Bar & Eatery Hawthorn Italian Restaurant est 2014 in Hawthorn follows on a 4.85, a reviewer's favourite Italian in Melbourne for its linguine busara, squid-ink pasta and lamb-ragu gnocchi.
Da Guido La Pasta in Carlton scores a 4.86 on a more refined menu, a wagyu ravioli and squid-ink seafood linguine room where a couple rate a ten-course tasting menu beautifully presented and perfectly timed. Sassy Italian Restaurant in West Melbourne pairs a lamb ravioli and fettuccine carbonara with a sticky date pudding diners keep naming the highlight of the night. Little Black Pig & Sons in Heidelberg scores the list's highest at 4.92, a tasting-menu room with fresh pasta and ragu that reviewers call one of the best value fine-dining experiences in Melbourne, worth the drive from the north west.
Max on Hardware in the city carries the deepest review count on the list, more than five thousand, on a homemade gnocchi buffalino and seafood risotto reviewers rate alongside the terrace and the set menu. ALT PASTA BAR in the city is the pasta-bar pick, a spanner-crab squid-ink pasta and Moreton Bay bug plate counter reviewers single out for the squid ink in particular. Tonda Italian in Preston turns out stuffed gnocchi and a pappardelle lamb ragu in a welcoming room reviewers call fresh and authentic.
The list closes across the inner suburbs. Rick's Place Italian Modern Australian & Gluten Free Restaurant in Kensington is the gluten-free-friendly room, a carbonara and seafood spaghetti allo scoglio kitchen where the owner's welcome draws repeat visits. Scopri Italian Food and Wine in Carlton runs handmade duck-ragu and pumpkin-agnolotti pasta with a truffle risotto reviewers rate among the best Italian in the city, Piccolo Mondo in Carlton backs a squid-ink spaghetti and seafood risotto with service reviewers name by waiter, and Berth in Docklands rounds it out, a fresh-seafood-pasta and scallop room diners call exceptional for a celebration.
Every kitchen here carries a Curateria Score drawn from its whole review history, then re-weighted toward the most recent hundred reviews so the order reflects how the kitchen cooks today rather than how it cooked two years ago. We hold the cohort to a tight inner-Melbourne radius, roughly 15km of the city, and drop the multi-location chains, so what is left reads as the real local order rather than a list of the loudest brands. That quality score is then blended with how often and how recently diners are still talking about a place. The corpus is Victorian and scored by us; no AI writer ever reads it. The ranking is arithmetic. The words are ours.
Explore more Pasta across Melbourne on Discover ->
Every venue here is ranked by its Curateria Score, a recent-review-weighted quality signal that leans on what diners are saying now, not years ago. Keep browsing Melbourne, sorted by Curateria Score, on Discover.
More from the Lowdown
Our read on where Melbourne is eating, drawn from every review we track. Free, no algorithm, unsubscribe in two clicks.