I Carusi Pizza

Curateria is an independent guide to Australia’s best restaurants, ranked from public reviews.

Closed nowOpens 5:30pmSunday: 5:30pm - 9:30pm
46A Holmes St, Brunswick East VIC 3057

The Lowdown · AI digest

How we read reviews →
AI Summary

Brunswick East's intimate Italian trattoria. family-run, homey, and voted best pizza in the suburb multiple times.

A cosy, warmly lit trattoria decorated with lemons, garlic, and festoon lights, playing traditional Italian music. Intimate and date-night-ready, with a homey feel that regulars compare to a tucked-away Sicilian family restaurant. Can get noisy when a large table fills the compact front room.

Staffed primarily by native Italian speakers. Family wine imported from the owner's vineyard in Italy. Voted best pizza in Brunswick multiple times. Operates dine-in and takeaway with quick turnaround on orders. Recent redecoration has lifted the ambience.

Italian-speaking staff and owner family wine from Italy lend genuine cultural credibility. Italian-born reviewers have praised it as the real thing; a small number of Italian-background reviewers have found the dough at odds with their personal tradition. The overall tilt is toward authentic rather than Australianised Italian.

Pricing sits at the moderate-to-higher end for a neighbourhood pizza joint. four large pizzas cost around $120+. Most regulars consider the quality of ingredients and experience worth the spend; a minority find it overpriced for the portion size and flag unusual charges (chilli oil, weekend surcharge). The family wine is considered good value by regulars.

Summary drafted with AI from public reviews.

Comparing options? See Golden Pizza nearby · 4.9
4.3Curateria Score
Latest reviews indexed0awaiting ingest
Google rating4.3 ★ · 205 reviews
How we score →

What people are posting

Photos & Social

On the Menu

Location & nearby

Open in map →

Loading map...

Address

46A Holmes St, Brunswick East VIC 3057

Neighbourhood

Brunswick East

Support our work

Help keep Curateria independent

Reader-supported, ad-light. Three ways to back the work.

Give a dining gift cardAffiliate Partner

Restaurant gift cards from Best Restaurants AU, redeemable at 1,000+ venues Australia-wide.

Give a dining gift card →

Curateria may receive a commission if you book or order through this link.

Similar nearby

See all →
Been here? Help others discover this place.
Review on Google

Your review helps the restaurant and the Curateria community.

Support our work

Help keep Curateria independent

Reader-supported, ad-light. Three ways to back the work.

Give a dining gift cardAffiliate Partner

Restaurant gift cards from Best Restaurants AU, redeemable at 1,000+ venues Australia-wide.

Give a dining gift card →

Curateria may receive a commission if you book or order through this link.

Featured in